Cooper Burns All articles
Tax and Budget

The Second Signature: Putting a Family Salary on a Proper Footing

Cooper Burns
The Second Signature: Putting a Family Salary on a Proper Footing

A family member on the payroll is not, in itself, a tax problem. HMRC does not object to relatives working in an owner-managed company, and many do so genuinely and productively. The difficulty arises when the arrangement exists mainly in the bank statement: money leaves the company each month, but there is little to show what was done, why the pay was set at that level, or how the relationship was documented. At that point, a straightforward family arrangement can start to look like something else — an informal distribution, a National Minimum Wage issue or an employment-status question that no one intended to create.

The test is not whether the person shares your surname. It is whether the company can evidence a real role, commercial pay, a proper contract and clean payroll records. Those four points should be settled before the first payment, not assembled afterwards if HMRC asks.

Begin with the job, not the relationship

The first question is what the family member actually does. A job description does not need to be elaborate, but it should identify the duties, the time commitment, who they report to and what decisions they are authorised to make. A spouse who handles credit control two days a week, manages supplier queries and prepares payment runs has a describable role. A spouse who occasionally answers the phone and is paid a monthly salary has a much weaker position.

A short board minute recording the appointment, the role and the agreed remuneration is useful evidence. It shows that the company turned its mind to the arrangement at the time. The minute should be consistent with the contract and the payroll records. If the role changes materially, update the paperwork rather than letting the original description become stale.

The family dimension can make this feel unnecessarily formal. It is not. A company is a separate legal person, and payments from it need a proper basis. The same discipline that applies to an unrelated employee should apply here, with perhaps a little more care because the relationship invites assumptions.

Pay that can be defended

The salary should be commensurate with the work. That does not mean it must match a full-time market rate if the role is part-time, but it should be explainable by reference to hours, duties and responsibility. A benchmark from a salary survey, a recruitment advert or advice from an adviser can be kept on file. The point is to show that the figure was considered, not simply chosen to use up a tax allowance.

Where the family member is a worker rather than an office-holder, the National Minimum Wage and National Living Wage must be checked against actual recorded hours. Family connection is not a blanket reason to ignore the statutory minimum, and the rules are fact-specific. If the role involves regular hours, record them. If the arrangement is casual, consider whether it genuinely is casual or whether it has become a regular commitment that should be paid and documented as such.

Pay also needs to be paid. A salary credited to a director's loan account, or netted off against personal expenses, is not the same as remuneration through payroll. If the company cannot afford the salary, the answer is to revisit the arrangement, not to leave unexplained balances in the accounts.

The contract is the anchor

A written contract of employment, or a written statement of particulars where appropriate, gives the arrangement its legal shape. It should cover duties, hours, place of work, pay, holiday, notice, confidentiality and the handling of company property. If the family member is also a director, a separate service agreement or board minute may be needed to record the director's terms.

The contract should be signed before work begins. A document created months later is better than nothing, but it is less convincing as evidence of what was agreed at the time. The terms should match reality: if the contract says twenty hours a week, the timesheets and payroll should not tell a different story.

This is also the point to separate employment from shareholding. A spouse may be both an employee and a shareholder, but the two capacities produce different payments and different paperwork. Salary is paid under the contract and through PAYE. Dividends are paid to shareholders from distributable profits, with the necessary board minutes and dividend vouchers. Mixing the two, or describing one as the other, creates avoidable risk.

RTI and the paper trail

Once the person is on the payroll, the company should register as an employer if it has not already done so, operate PAYE and report payments through Real Time Information. Each payday should produce a full payment submission, and the employee should receive payslips. Year-end declarations and P60s should follow in the normal way.

The paper trail should be complete enough that someone unfamiliar with the family could follow it. That means a contract, a job description, a board minute, payroll records, timesheets where hours matter, bank payments and, where relevant, dividend vouchers. It also means keeping personal and company money separate. A salary paid into a joint account is fine if the records identify it clearly; a series of unexplained transfers is not.

Expenses and benefits deserve the same attention. A family member may receive a company car, private medical cover or a home office allowance. These should be reported and taxed according to the normal rules. The fact that the recipient is related to the director does not make the benefit invisible.

The dividend boundary

Owner-managed companies often use a combination of salary and dividends. That can be tax-efficient, but only if each element is properly characterised. A salary that is not paid through payroll, or a dividend paid without distributable profits and the correct records, may be reclassified on review. HMRC is entitled to look at substance rather than labels.

The safer approach is to decide in advance how the family member will be remunerated, document that decision, and keep the salary and dividend streams separate. If the company has insufficient distributable profits, a dividend should not be used to top up the salary. If the salary is not commercially justified, increasing it to reduce corporation tax is unlikely to withstand scrutiny.

Employment status is a question of fact

Calling a family member self-employed does not settle their status. The tribunal and HMRC look at control, integration, mutuality of obligation and the reality of the working relationship. A person who works set hours, takes instructions and is integrated into the business may be an employee in substance, whatever the invoice says. For a small company engaging a family member, the simplest and most defensible route is usually to treat a genuine employee as an employee.

A pre-payroll checklist

Before the first payment, the company should be able to answer yes to the following: is there a written role description; is the pay supported by a commercial rationale; is there a signed contract; has the payroll been set up; will RTI submissions be made on time; are hours recorded where they matter; is there a board minute; are salary and dividends kept separate; and will the arrangement be reviewed annually?

A family salary can be a practical way to reward real work and to share the burden of running a business. The paperwork is not there to make family life bureaucratic. It is there to show that the company acted deliberately, that the pay was earned and that the tax treatment follows the facts. Put that in place before the second signature, and the arrangement is far more likely to withstand a question later.

This article is general guidance and is not a substitute for advice on the particular facts of a company or individual.

All Articles

Related Articles

Drawing from the Company: A Working Guide to the Director's Loan Account

Drawing from the Company: A Working Guide to the Director's Loan Account

The Orderly Transfer: Replacing Your Accountant Without a Filing Gap

The Orderly Transfer: Replacing Your Accountant Without a Filing Gap

Dividend Discipline: The Records to Put in Place Before You Draw from the Company

Dividend Discipline: The Records to Put in Place Before You Draw from the Company