Dividend Discipline: The Records to Put in Place Before You Draw from the Company
Photo: Francisclarke, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons
Begin with company law, not just the tax outcome
For an owner-manager, taking money out of the company can feel like a private matter between director and business. In law it is not. A dividend is a distribution of the company’s profits, and the Companies Act 2006 places limits on when a company may make one. The company must have distributable profits available at the time of the distribution. Those profits are not the same as the cash balance in the bank. They are built from accumulated realised profits less accumulated realised losses, subject to the relevant accounts and any restrictions in the articles.
The practical point is simple. Before money leaves the company as a dividend, the director should be able to show that the board considered the company’s financial position and resolved to declare the dividend. Tax treatment follows the company law position; it does not cure a distribution that should not have been made.
The records that should exist before the transfer
A well-kept dividend file does not need to be elaborate, but it should tell a coherent story. In most small companies, three records sit at the centre.
First, a board minute. The directors should record the decision to declare a dividend, the date of the decision, the amount, the shares to which it relates and the basis on which the directors satisfied themselves that distributable profits were available. For a small company with one director, this can be a short written resolution, but it should still be prepared at the time and kept with the company’s records.
Second, a dividend voucher. Each shareholder should receive a voucher showing the company name, the shareholder’s name, the date, the amount, the number and class of shares held and the amount per share. The voucher is evidence of the distribution and helps support the shareholder’s tax position. It should be issued when the dividend is declared or paid, not reconstructed months later as an afterthought.
Third, the accounts or management figures relied on. The directors do not need a full audit to declare an interim dividend, but they do need a reasonable basis for concluding that profits are available. That may be the latest statutory accounts, up-to-date management accounts or a profit and loss forecast supported by the accounting records. The record should show what was considered, not merely that a figure was mentioned in conversation.
Shortcuts that turn a dividend into a loan account issue
The most common problem is not a deliberate attempt to avoid tax. It is informality. A director transfers money monthly, describes it as drawings, and intends to sort out the dividend paperwork at the year end. If the company later cannot show that profits were available, or the correct records were never created, the payment may be treated as a loan from the company to the director. That can bring a director’s loan account into being, with possible tax consequences for the company and a benefit-in-kind question for the director.
A second shortcut is to treat the bank balance as proof of profit. A company can hold cash from a loan, from customer deposits for future work or from the sale of an asset. None of those is necessarily distributable profit. A dividend declared on that basis may be unlawful, even if the bank account looks healthy.
A third is to leave the paperwork until after the accounts are filed. Reconstructing a dividend after the event is not automatically wrong, but it should reflect what actually happened. Backdating documents to create a cleaner record is a different matter and should be avoided.
If the paperwork is missing
Missing dividend records should be dealt with calmly and honestly. Start by gathering the evidence that does exist: bank statements, accounting records, emails, meeting notes, previous accounts and any dividend vouchers. Establish what was paid, when, to whom and what the company’s financial position was at the time.
If the payment can properly be supported as a dividend, the company may be able to put a contemporaneous record in place now, with a board minute and voucher that accurately reflect the original decision as far as it can be evidenced. If the payment cannot be supported because profits were not available, the director should take advice. The payment may need to be reclassified as a loan, repaid or set against a later lawful dividend or salary. In some cases, disclosure to HMRC may be appropriate. The right answer depends on the facts, which is why professional advice is worth taking before the position is corrected.
The important point is to avoid both panic and pretence. A director who identifies the problem and takes orderly steps to correct it is in a far better position than one who allows an unexplained loan account to grow.
A short pre-payment routine
Before drawing a dividend, a director should be able to answer three questions. Are there sufficient distributable profits on the relevant accounts? Has the board properly resolved to declare the dividend? Has a voucher been prepared for each shareholder? If the answer to any of these is no, the payment should wait or be treated as something else with proper advice.
Cooper Burns encourages directors to treat the dividend file as part of ordinary governance, not as a year-end chore. The records need not be long. They need to exist before the money moves, and they need to be accurate.