The Orderly Transfer: Replacing Your Accountant Without a Filing Gap
Photo: UK accountant handover paperwork office desk, via s3.amazonaws.com
Changing accountant is not, in itself, a compliance risk. The risk lies in the fortnight when neither firm is sure who is responsible for the next VAT return, the payroll submission or the annual accounts. For a UK director, the statutory duties remain with the company throughout. The practical task is therefore to create an orderly transfer with a clear cut-off, a complete handover and a new engagement that names the work to be done.
Fix the cut-off date before comparing firms
Before you discuss fees or sign a new engagement letter, choose an effective date for the change. Put it in writing to the outgoing firm in line with the notice provisions in its engagement terms. A cut-off immediately after a filed return is usually easier to manage than one in the middle of a quarter. Avoid month-end, a payroll run, a VAT period end and the weeks immediately before annual accounts are approved.
The date should be realistic. If the outgoing firm is completing a set of accounts or a corporation tax return, allow it to finish that piece of work or agree expressly that it will stop. A half-finished filing is worse than a slightly later start.
Build a handover pack, not a memory stick
A director should ask for a structured handover rather than a bundle of files. The exact list depends on the company, but it will usually include:
- the nominal ledger, trial balance and prior statutory accounts;
- bank reconciliations and supporting schedules;
- VAT returns, workings and correspondence;
- payroll records, RTI submissions and expenses information;
- corporation tax computations and returns;
- Companies House filings and the authentication code for online filing;
- the fixed asset register and any loan or hire purchase schedules;
- accounting software access, including the ability to export the data;
- HMRC agent authorisations for VAT, PAYE and Corporation Tax.
The company owns its accounting records. The outgoing firm may retain copies for its own regulatory and professional reasons, but it should not treat the records as its property. Ask for the handover in a usable format, not only as PDFs. If the software subscription is in the outgoing firm's name, agree how it will be transferred or replaced before the cut-off date.
Time the move around VAT, payroll and annual accounts
VAT is often the first pressure point. If the company submits quarterly returns, the simplest date is after a return has been filed and any payment collected. Do not allow a return to fall between firms without a named preparer and a named reviewer.
Payroll has a shorter rhythm. A change in the middle of a pay period can work, but only if the new firm has the year-to-date figures and the previous submissions. Confirm who will run the next payroll, who will make the RTI submission and who will deal with any HMRC query.
Annual accounts need more forward planning. A private company generally has nine months after its accounting reference date to file accounts at Companies House, although first accounts follow different rules. The corporation tax return is due later, but the computations and the accounts still need to be prepared. If the filing deadline is close, consider letting the outgoing firm complete the statutory accounts and starting the new firm afterwards. If that is not possible, the new firm must have enough time to review opening balances, prior filings and the accounting policies before it signs anything.
The confirmation statement is easy to overlook because it is not a tax return. Add it to the new filing calendar at the outset, together with any other recurring obligations.
Ask for professional clearance and control the permissions
A new firm will normally seek professional clearance from the outgoing accountant before accepting appointment. The outgoing firm should respond promptly, although it is not entitled to withhold the company's records. This step is routine, but it should not be left until the last week.
Agent authorisations also need attention. Adding a new agent does not always remove the old one. Review the position with HMRC so that only the intended firm can act for VAT, PAYE and Corporation Tax. Check the Companies House authentication code and the accounting software administrator rights. A change of accountant should not leave a former adviser with live access that no one has reviewed.
Questions to settle before signing the engagement letter
The engagement letter is the moment to remove ambiguity. Ask the new firm:
- Which services are included: statutory accounts, corporation tax, VAT, payroll, bookkeeping, management accounts or ad hoc advice?
- Is the fee fixed, hourly or based on a scope that can change? What triggers an additional charge?
- Who will prepare the work and who will review it?
- Will the firm provide a filing calendar and tell us what it needs from us, and by when?
- Who will monitor HMRC correspondence and deadlines?
- How will records be held, backed up and returned if the engagement ends?
- What is the notice period, and what happens to work in progress?
- Does the firm hold professional indemnity insurance?
A director does not need to interrogate every technical point, but the allocation of responsibility should be clear. The company remains responsible for filing on time. The engagement letter should make it obvious how the firm will help the company meet that duty.
The first month after appointment
The new firm should reconcile opening balances, agree the prior returns and test the opening position before the next deadline arrives. The director should keep a copy of the signed engagement letter, the handover list and the final invoice from the outgoing firm. Confirm in writing that the old firm has ceased work and that the new firm has the access it needs.
A change of accountant should be a transfer of responsibility, not a break in it. The director who sets a date, keeps the records and asks the engagement questions before signature is in a stronger position than one who simply stops returning calls.