Cooper Burns All articles
Legal and Governance

Dear New Director: An Honest Letter About the Job Behind the Title

Cooper Burns
Dear New Director: An Honest Letter About the Job Behind the Title

Photo: Church of the Brethren. Districts. Eastern Pennsylvania. [from old catalog], No restrictions, via Wikimedia Commons

Dear newly appointed director,

Congratulations. The appointment is a vote of confidence, and it carries more than a title. It carries duties that are personal, not always delegable, and occasionally uncomfortable. Most people learn them in the order in which they cause trouble. This letter is an attempt to shorten that process.

The company is not you

A limited company is a separate legal person. That separation is the whole point of incorporation, and it is why the company's debts are not automatically yours. But limited liability is a condition, not a gift. It depends on the company being run honestly, with proper records, and with the directors acting in its interests rather than their own. When that condition is broken, the protection thins quickly.

Read the paper with your signature on it

Before you sign a personal guarantee, read it twice and assume the worst case. A guarantee can expose your home, your savings and your future income, and it often survives the sale of the business. Some are capped; many are not. A guarantee and an indemnity are different instruments, and the difference matters when a lender calls.

If a guarantee is demanded, negotiate. Ask for a cap, a time limit, or a release on the sale of the company. Ask whether the bank would accept lesser security. The moment to do this is before signature, not after a demand letter arrives.

Salary and dividends are decisions, not habits

The split between salary and dividends is a tax question, but it is also a governance question. Salary is a deductible cost for the company and carries PAYE and National Insurance. Dividends are paid from profits after tax, require distributable reserves, and need a board decision and a dividend voucher. The dividend allowance is modest and the rates are not.

The trap is treating dividends as a monthly wage. If there are no reserves, the dividend is unlawful, and an unlawful dividend can be recovered from the recipient. If the company has had a poor year, the pattern may need to change. Take advice on your own numbers rather than copying a structure from another business.

The records are yours in law

The company must keep accounting records, statutory registers, minutes of board and shareholder decisions, and a register of people with significant control. Directors must declare interests in transactions. Service contracts and conflicts need to be documented. Accounting records generally need to be kept for six years.

Your accountant can prepare the accounts, but cannot discharge your duty to ensure the company keeps proper records. When a dispute or an investigation arrives, the quality of the minute book is often as important as the quality of the numbers.

When the ground moves

If the company is heading towards insolvency, the duties change. Directors must have regard to the interests of creditors, and continuing to trade when there is no reasonable prospect of avoiding insolvent liquidation can amount to wrongful trading. That can lead to personal liability and, in serious cases, disqualification.

The Supreme Court considered the creditor duty in 2022 in BTI v Sequana, and the practical message is straightforward: when solvency is in doubt, take advice early and document the reasoning. Do not wait for a statutory demand. Do not pay yourself while suppliers go unpaid. Do not assume that an overdraft is a substitute for a plan.

The early warning signs

Watch for these: a cash forecast that is negative in the next three months; arrears with HMRC, particularly a time to pay arrangement that has slipped; supplier pressure or county court claims; late statutory accounts; an overdrawn director's loan that is growing; the loss of a major customer; and a set of management accounts you cannot explain.

Each is manageable on its own. Several together usually mean the business model needs attention, not just the bank balance.

Build a small circle of people who will tell you the truth

An accountant who explains rather than merely files. A solicitor who reads the documents properly. A non-executive or mentor who has seen a downturn before. A board that asks questions. The cost of these relationships is modest compared with the cost of learning alone.

Ask naive questions. It is far cheaper to ask why the loan account is overdrawn than to explain later why it was never repaid.

The first ninety days

Read the last two years of accounts and the current management accounts. Confirm the company's filing position at Companies House. Find out whether you have signed any guarantees. Check the dividend history and the loan account. Meet the bank and the accountant. Read the articles of association. Then write down the three things that worry you most and deal with them.

The title is not the job. The job is judgement, records and timing. Get those broadly right and the rest becomes manageable.

Yours, Cooper Burns

All Articles

Related Articles

Trust Is Not a Substitute for Terms: Five Documents for Small UK Companies

Trust Is Not a Substitute for Terms: Five Documents for Small UK Companies

Year-End Triage: A Director's Order of Work Before the Accounts Close

Year-End Triage: A Director's Order of Work Before the Accounts Close

After the Budget Headlines: A Calm Review for UK Business Owners

After the Budget Headlines: A Calm Review for UK Business Owners