Trust Is Not a Substitute for Terms: Five Documents for Small UK Companies
Photo: Francisclarke, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons
Small companies are often built on trust. Founders work late together, directors cover for one another, and early customers are won through personal relationships. That trust is valuable. It is not, however, a substitute for a written record.
The point is not to assume the worst of your fellow directors or your best customer. It is to make sure that when circumstances change, everyone is working from the same terms. A misunderstanding that could have been resolved by a short document can become an expensive dispute once money, intellectual property or control of the company is involved.
The five documents below are not paranoid paperwork. They are the foundations of a company that can explain its own arrangements.
1. A shareholders' agreement
A company's articles of association set out certain constitutional rules, but they rarely cover every practical question that arises between shareholders. A shareholders' agreement can deal with the matters that matter most when there are two or more owners.
It should address decision-making, deadlock, share transfers, minority protection, dividend policy and what happens if a shareholder wants to leave. It can also set out how valuations are handled and how disputes are resolved before they reach a courtroom.
For a small company, the value of the agreement is often in the conversations that take place before it is signed. Who decides on a new director? Can one shareholder sell to a third party? What happens if a shareholder dies or becomes unable to work? These questions are easier to answer calmly at the start than during a crisis.
Review the agreement when the ownership changes or when new investment is contemplated. A document signed by two founders may not fit a company with five shareholders and an outside investor.
2. Directors' service contracts
A director is not automatically an employee, and an appointment letter is not automatically a service contract. For a small company, the key is to have a written record of the arrangement that reflects what is actually happening.
The document should cover duties, time commitment, remuneration, expenses, confidentiality, intellectual property, notice and termination. If restrictive covenants are intended, they need to be drafted carefully and tailored to the role. A generic clause copied from another business may not be enforceable.
Where a director is also a shareholder, keep the two roles distinct. The service contract deals with the director's work for the company. The shareholders' agreement deals with the ownership relationship. Mixing the two can create confusion when one role ends and the other continues.
Company law also imposes duties on directors. A written contract does not replace those duties, but it can help everyone understand what is expected in practice.
3. Intellectual property assignments
A company's most valuable assets are often intangible: its brand, its software, its content, its designs and its customer lists. It is surprisingly common for a small company to assume it owns those assets when the legal position is less clear.
Employees may create intellectual property in the course of their employment, but the position should still be documented. Contractors and freelancers generally need a written assignment if the company is to own the rights they create. That includes designers, developers, copywriters and consultants.
Check the position for logos, websites, software, photographs and written content. Also consider domain names and social media accounts. Who controls the login? Is the account registered in the company's name? If a founder leaves, can the company recover the accounts and the content?
Where trademarks are important, consider registration. An assignment of copyright is not the same as a registered trademark, and a trading name is not automatically protected.
4. Commercial terms
Every company sells something, whether goods, services, software or advice. The commercial terms should set out what is being supplied, the price, payment terms, delivery, risk, warranties, liability and what happens if either side wants to end the arrangement.
For business-to-business sales, standard terms can be incorporated into quotations and order forms. For consumer sales, different rules apply and the terms need to reflect consumer law. Website terms, order forms and invoices should be consistent with the main contract rather than contradicting it.
Small companies often rely on a short email or a purchase order. That can work, but it is fragile. If a customer later disputes the scope of work or refuses to pay, the company needs to be able to show what was agreed. A clear set of terms, provided at the right time, is far cheaper than reconstructing the deal after a disagreement.
5. A simple exit plan
An exit plan is not only for companies preparing for a sale. It is a record of how owners can leave, retire, sell their shares or bring in a successor. It also deals with what happens if a shareholder dies or becomes incapacitated.
For many small companies, the exit plan sits within the shareholders' agreement. It may include buy-sell provisions, a valuation method, insurance arrangements and a timetable. The important point is that the plan is written down and reviewed.
A simple exit plan can also address deadlock. If two owners cannot agree, what happens? A deadlock provision may give one party a route to buy the other out, or require mediation before litigation. These clauses are not a sign of distrust. They are a sign that the owners have thought about the future while they still agree on the basics.
Keeping the documents alive
A document signed five years ago may no longer reflect the company. New shareholders, new directors, new products and new customers can all change the risk profile. Review the set annually, or whenever there is a significant event: investment, a new shareholder, a key hire, a new contract or a planned exit.
Store signed copies where they can be found. A document that exists but cannot be located is only slightly better than one that was never signed. Keep a simple register of contracts and note the review date.
These five documents will not eliminate disagreement. They will, however, make it easier to resolve. They give the company a record of what was agreed, and they allow advisers to give useful advice rather than reconstructing history. If you trust everyone involved, put the terms in writing. That is not pessimism. It is good governance.