The Guarantee Before the Signature: Five Questions for a Director
Photo: Scottish Government, CC BY 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons
Personal guarantees are common in UK business lending, commercial leases and supplier credit. They are also frequently signed at the end of a meeting, when the commercial deal is agreed and the paperwork is treated as an afterthought. That is a mistake. A guarantee is a separate contract, often enforceable without the company having to fail first, and its terms deserve the same attention as the loan or lease itself.
The following questions are not a substitute for legal advice. They are a director's diligence list.
1. What exactly am I guaranteeing?
A guarantee is a promise to meet another party's obligation if that party does not. But which obligation? The answer should be in the guarantee document, not in the term sheet or the conversation.
Check whether the guarantee covers a specific facility, a lease, a supply agreement or all present and future obligations to the lender. An all-monies guarantee can extend to new lending, variations, interest, fees and enforcement costs. Check whether the company is the only principal debtor or whether a co-guarantor is also liable. Look for words such as principal debtor, indemnity, joint and several and continuing security. Each has a legal effect.
Also check the identity of the parties. A guarantee signed by the wrong company, or by an individual without authority, can create personal exposure without the benefit intended.
2. How much could I owe, and for how long?
Ask for a cap. A guarantee without a limit can expose the guarantor to the full debt plus interest and costs. A capped guarantee should state the cap clearly and say whether the cap includes interest, fees and enforcement costs or sits on top of them. If the cap is described as a percentage, check the percentage of what.
Time matters too. Is the guarantee limited to a defined period, or does it continue until the lender releases it? Does it survive repayment and re-borrowing? A continuing guarantee can be revived by later advances. Ask what event releases the guarantee: repayment in full, a replacement guarantee, the sale of the business or a set date. Get the release mechanism in writing.
3. When can a demand be made, and what happens on default?
A guarantee may be payable on demand, which means the lender can call for payment once the specified default occurs, sometimes without first pursuing the company. Check whether the guarantee is conditional on the lender exhausting its remedies against the company. Many are not.
On default, the guarantor may face a demand, interest, legal costs and enforcement against personal assets, including a charging order or bankruptcy petition. If the guarantee is joint and several, each guarantor may be pursued for the whole amount, leaving them to recover contributions from the others. If there is security, such as a charge over a home, the guarantee and the security documents should be read together.
Ask what notice the lender must give, what evidence of the debt must be provided and whether the guarantor can challenge the amount. A well-drafted guarantee will not leave those points to chance.
4. What can I negotiate?
More than many directors assume. A lender may accept a cap, a time limit, a release on the sale of the business, a requirement to notify the guarantor of changes, or a limit on costs. A landlord may accept a guarantee for a shorter period, or a rent deposit instead of a personal guarantee. A supplier may accept a lower credit limit.
Look for protections such as: no variation of the underlying contract without consent; no release of other security without consent; a requirement to account for recoveries; and a right to step into the lender's position after payment. These are not standard in every deal, but they are worth asking for before signature.
Do not assume that because a guarantee is described as standard, it cannot be amended. Commercial terms are often more flexible than the first draft suggests.
5. Who has reviewed it, and what is the exit?
A second pair of eyes is worth the fee. Independent legal advice is particularly important where the guarantee is unlimited, secured on a home, given by a spouse or connected person, or accompanied by an indemnity. The adviser should see the guarantee, the underlying facility or lease, and any security documents together.
Ask your accountant to model the downside: if the company fails, what is the realistic personal exposure? Ask your solicitor to explain the demand mechanics and any defects in the drafting. Keep a copy of the final signed documents and a note of the advice received.
Finally, decide before signing how the guarantee will be monitored. Diarise the review date, the release conditions and any covenant that affects the guarantee. A guarantee that is forgotten is a guarantee that is not managed.
A personal guarantee can be a reasonable part of a funding package. It should not be a surprise. If the document cannot be explained in plain English before signature, it is not ready to sign.