Before the Odometer Moves: A Director’s Mileage Record That Holds
Photo: Custom Neon Images, CC BY 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons
A mileage claim rarely fails because the journey did not happen. It fails because the file cannot show why it happened, when it happened, or in whose vehicle. For a UK director, the practical answer is not a more elaborate spreadsheet. It is a routine that begins before the car leaves the kerb.
First, establish whose vehicle it is
There are two broad routes for car travel through a company, and they should not be blended.
Where the director owns the vehicle and uses it for company business, the company may pay approved mileage allowance payments, usually called AMAPs. Those payments are tax-free up to the approved limits, and the company can generally deduct them as a business cost. The director records business miles and keeps evidence of the journeys.
Where the company owns or leases the vehicle, the position is different. A company car normally gives rise to a benefit-in-kind charge. Mileage allowance payments are not the usual mechanism. Instead, the company may reimburse business fuel at HMRC’s advisory fuel rates, and private fuel must be either repaid or treated as a taxable benefit. Mixing the two regimes is a common and avoidable error.
A director should decide, in writing, which arrangement applies. That note belongs with the company’s expenses policy, not in someone’s memory.
The rates are a ceiling, not a target
For cars and vans, the current approved mileage rates are 45p per mile for the first 10,000 business miles in a tax year, and 25p per mile after that. Motorcycles attract 24p per mile and bicycles 20p per mile. These are limits for tax-free payment, not a mandatory rate.
If the company pays more than the approved amount, the excess is generally taxable. If it pays less, the director may be able to claim tax relief on the shortfall through a tax return. A director who simply claims the maximum without checking the actual business miles has turned a useful relief into an audit risk.
A simple policy is better than an annual argument: state the rate, state the cap, state the evidence required, and apply it consistently.
What makes a mile business mileage?
Ordinary commuting between home and a permanent workplace is private travel. It does not become business mileage because the director works late, carries papers, or takes a laptop home. Travel to a temporary workplace can be different, but the rules are fact-sensitive, particularly where a director works from home for part of the week.
Genuine business journeys include visits to clients, suppliers, banks, solicitors, accountants, and temporary sites. The record should explain the purpose, not merely the destination. “Went to Leeds” is weak. “Meeting with northern supplier about 2027 contract, Leeds office, returned same day” is useful.
Private detours should be excluded. If a business trip includes a private diversion, apportion the miles and keep a note of the reasoning. A claim does not need to be perfect to be credible, but it does need to be honest.
A monthly log does the real work
A mileage log kept at the end of the year is a reconstruction. A log kept monthly is evidence. The difference matters when an accountant, payroll provider, or HMRC officer asks for support.
A workable log should capture the date, vehicle registration, start and finish odometer readings where available, total miles, business miles, the journey’s origin and destination, and the business purpose. For electric vehicles, record the same journey details and any charging costs separately if the company reimburses them.
Supporting evidence need not be elaborate. Calendar entries, appointment confirmations, parking receipts, toll records, and fuel or charging receipts all help. The strongest file combines a contemporaneous log with one or two independent records for unusual journeys.
At each month end, reconcile the log to the vehicle’s odometer and to the expense claim. If the numbers do not agree, resolve the difference then, not eleven months later.
Company-owned cars need a different discipline
Where the company provides the car, the director should not submit AMAP claims for the same journeys. Business fuel can be reimbursed at the advisory fuel rate, supported by a fuel log and receipts. Private fuel should be repaid to the company or reported as a benefit. The P11D process should reflect the car and fuel position accurately.
Electric company cars are not outside the record-keeping requirement. If the company reimburses electricity for business charging, the advisory electricity rate may apply, and the same journey evidence is needed. The benefit-in-kind position for the car itself still applies.
The failures that attract attention
Most problems are predictable. A round-sum monthly allowance with no mileage record. A claim for 500 miles described only as “travel”. The same journey claimed twice, once through expenses and once through payroll. A company car driver claiming AMAPs. A director claiming home-to-office travel as business mileage every day.
None of these requires bad faith. They usually begin with convenience. But once a pattern is set, it is difficult to unwind without either repaying money or producing records that do not exist.
A short routine, applied every month
The director should review the mileage log before the monthly expense run, approve it, and file it with the claim. The company should keep the record for at least six years from the end of the accounting period, and longer if there is a query. The accountant should receive a clean summary rather than a shoebox of petrol receipts.
A mileage claim does not need to be complicated. It needs to be contemporaneous, connected to a business purpose, and consistent with the vehicle arrangement. Set the policy once, keep the log monthly, and the claim will be far easier to defend when someone asks.
This article is general guidance for UK business owners and is not a substitute for advice on a specific set of facts.